9 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Pearson's avatar

"Whether it's good value or not" has always been my favorite Sietsema differentiator. The concept of value can also be applied to the time and energy required to get the reservation or endure the line. It does feel like a eating has become gamified so that a person can say, "I ate there!" As if the capturing of this pokemon...err experience were the whole point. I also agree about the "foodie" term becoming rather trite. To refer to oneself as a "foodie" today feels to me like the equivalent of writing in a dating profile that you "love life" or "love to laugh." A recent dating show contestant referred to herself as "a huge foodie" and then when questioned about her favorite food she responded "burritos." Don't get me wrong, I love burritos, but I don't think that's what the foodie forefathers had in mind.

Expand full comment
Will Hermes's avatar

Real talk. Thanks for this. I miss the days of combing sidestreets in Flushing for standout hole-in-the-wall joints, usually with your columns as cheat sheets. Hard to miss certain parallels with music culture and music journalism, sad to say.

Expand full comment
Jigar Parikh's avatar

I am reminded of the first restaurant guide I ever purchased when I arrived to the city in 1994. Your Good and Cheap Ethnic Eats For Under $10.

Expand full comment
Vinod Kumar's avatar

As a restaurant owner, I am at the frontline of this change. A lot of what you are saying is accurate. But it also feels like an homage to “good old days “. Yes, the concept of a foodie is changing with times. It would be more interesting and valuable to explore the upside of this change as well. Just a thought

Expand full comment
Daniel Cowells's avatar

Agree. The constant search for frivolous novelty is both exhausting and boring. Let it die.

Expand full comment
CS M's avatar

As a retired Yacht Chef from the 90’s/early aughts who absolutely Lived for my monthly Food & Wine, Bon Appetite & Cooks Illustrated & waited like an addict for my monthly editions to catch up with me, down island, via snail mail or along w/my drop shipped provisions I couldn’t agree more there’s Nothing that even comes close to Holding these glossy tactile food “museums” in your hands & later admiring them on your Galley bookshelf ♥️😢

Expand full comment
Christina Ariadne's avatar

There’s still places around the country where a “night out” still means what it used to, they tend to not be trending, and don’t want to be

Expand full comment
Harrison's avatar

Hahahah that disguise is too good!

Expand full comment
Marc's avatar

brother what the hell is stopping you? everyone's lining up to eat over-hyped over-advertised mediocrity and you can't just go eat what you want?

Expand full comment